The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20100810065327/http://myweb.cableone.net:80/kd7aoi/guest.htm

Heliography

(Communicating with Mirrors)

by James Riddle - KD7AOI


Home What's New Definitions Tips Event Photos Homemade Hg's Map of Hg Sites Space Age Hg Prehistoric Hg's Build Your Own Hg Related Links Our Group Guest Comments Feedback

 

Guests' Comments

The author's apology for not having posted comments since July, 2004.  Data, especially emails, were lost as a result of two major computer crashes.  Attempts are being made to recover at least some of the lost data.  Also, organizing the data for webposting is quite time consuming.  jhr May 8, 2005.

Jim White      Hudson, N. H.  (Hudson, FL)     K1EXE     08 Jul 2004             I was just sitting here watching "She Wore a Yellow Ribbon" on TV, and got to thinking about Heliograph usage in the last century..(lots of desert scenes) - I did a "Thing" on Heliographs while in Grade school, (late 1940's) and, until I read your website, I never knew about the British "Mance" units, and other "Portuguese" units.. My research (as a child) showed that heliograph communication could be carried on over 100+ mile paths, due to clearer air back then.. I am a "Ham" operator, and therefore, use Morse code to communicate, and learned Signal Flag usage in the Navy in 1957.. (as did everyone back then) I have carried a mental picture of the "ancient" Heliographs ever since school days.. The ones I remember used a long plank with pivoted square mirrors mounted on the rear, and an open frame with cross hairs stretched across on the front end. "Keying" was done with a paddle to block the light path.. Your sight is very interesting, and also I have studied the old movie "The Walking Hills" but, was somewhat disappointed with their coverage of the Heliograph, sometimes thinking that the prop man did not have a firm idea of what it was supposed to look like, or how it was to be used. Nevertheless, keep up the good work, I have wanted to build a "real" heliograph for many years, but, have pushed it aside for other things many times. I envy you your Southwest location, and it's history,..' 73 Jim White K1EXE

Iain Fulton     Livadia ,Tilos   walkertilos  Greece  18 Apr 2004     Not a comment more of an enquiery. Excellent site, and very informative, you really know your stuff. The question I hope you may be able to answer is, do you know if the Italien occupation forces in Greece ever used heliographs? My wife and I live on a small Greek island called Tilos, where we take people on guided walks. On one of the higher peaks they built a military communications station around 1932 and we are told that this used wireless and heliograghy systems but can find no further information despite hours trawling the internet. Hope you can clear this up. Best wishes with your site. Iain

Maj. Patrick Sheehan      Perry, Utah    07 Jul 2003                Hello,  I have just become interested in the operational use of the heliograph as a topic for a Command and General Staff College paper (I am a reserve officer currently on active duty). I have found this website to be quite fascinating and would like to get on your email list.  I have also become interested in acquiring an actual heliograph.  Any suggestions as to where to look?  I have seen a few on ebay but due to my schedule haven't been near the computer near end of auction and have always been outbid.  Many thanks.   Pat Sheehan    [I find eBay to be the most reliable, continuing source of heliographs, mostly the Mark V, a model patterned after Sir Henry Mance's original 1870s patented model.  Yes, there usually is a bidding scramble in the last couple of minutes, so most early bidding only tends to raise the price.  Hang in there, and good luck to you....... Jim]

******************************************

Tom Shaughnessy        Richardson     TX    06 Jul 2003           Back when I was 15 years old(1958) my best friend and I each purchased a British Mk V 5" heliograph at Earl Swendson's Gunshop on Harlem Ave. Chicago, Il.  Earl Had about 20 brand new instruments in their original leather cases with tripods priced at $10.00 complete.  My friend and I thought they were about as "cool" a thing as we had ever seen!  Earl held our choices on "layaway" for several weeks until we were able to mow enough lawns to pay them off.  My friend and I lived on the same street but 7 blocks apart.  After figuring out how the "key" worked we each set ours up on the sidewalk in front of our house.  After some "fiddling" we were successfully exchanging flashes. Neither of us knew any Morse (and still don't) but we never the less felt we were great successes.  I�ve lost contact with my friend over the years so I don't know if he still cherishes his Mk V.  I've kept mine locked away and have set it up at different times over the years for each of my four kiddos hoping they would appreciate a truly "cool" thing...the outcome of these exposures remains to be seen.  This is a really terrific site..nice work! 

******************************************

Edward Zeranski           Jun 30, 2003          (e-mail)              James,  I'd hoped to catch you at Ft. Tuthill but it looks my work will have me on the road. We did have some helio-fun at the West Coast Military Radio Collector's Group annual get-together thanks to Bart [Rowlett] and his gear. �.  EdZ

******************************************

Ian Church         England         23 Jun 2003        Hello James, excellent web site. I belong to a Victorian history group here in England, our signals unit use the Heliograph in our displays [circa 1880's ]. I have a few sets of helios, including an early hand held one. I am no expert on the subject, but I do like the construction of the equipment. Would you be able to point me in the right direction to identify the Helios I have? regards Ian @@@

******************************************

Gary Wallace    N7JZN          Pleasant Grove , Utah    22 Jun 2003       Mirror Mirror on the wall      Who has HelioGraph info at all?      I went to the Brigham Young University library a couple years before the Boy Scouts "On Target"  mountain top mirror activity.
Found a picture in a dictionary and that was all. Finally looked in the US Patent Gazette and found a dozen patents in the late 1800s. These have drawings and pages of explanations.  If you can go to a big University or big city public library that is a patent or Gov't repository (spell?) and goes back to that era there's the info at all.    We did night work from Orem City to Lake mountain (8 miles)  The city guy had a super flashlight like a million candlepower. It took a few minutes to pick him out of all the city lites.  (he wouldn't do any Morse code as I think he forgot it...  even tho he was a General class ham)  When recording Morse you can have someone write down the dots and dashes.  Use / s for dots as it is hard and slow to make a .   Thus  O K  would  read   - - -   - / -     One can later decode the dots and dashes. (this has been done to pass the Novice test although it's fudging things.)   We did the flashlite thing to a rural site and it worked well. also used car headlites    Would like to see the On Target use code in spite of Hams only being able to read code with sound.    Aloha    Gary N7JZN  [Mny tnx, Gary for your letter.  Your history with signalling using mirrors and lights before "Operation On Target" is nothing short of exciting.  Will be posting your letter to my website, and have added your name to my mailing list...Jim kd7aoi]

******************************************

Jeff Ross    Phoenix AZ   16 Jun 2003    do you have any info about the station on wheeler peak near baker nevada. i think it was in operation in the 1860's  [Hi Jeff,  No, sorry, never heard of it.  Don't believe there were any heliograph stations in operation in the west before 1880's.  But after so stating, I did find information at http://www.ddgps.com/outdoor_fun/nevada-great-basin.htm regarding Wheeler Peak and other Nevada peaks being used by the USCGS beginning in 1881 as heliograph/surveying sites.  So, 1860's, no, 1880's, maybe.  Note:  Permissions are needed for any publication of information from the aforementioned website.]

******************************************

Michael Louthan      13 Jun 2003     I'm seeking a bit of info on a heliograph I have had since I was 10-12, which was 1965 or so. I bought it at an Army Surplus store in Oklahoma.  It appears to be exactly like the "Mark V Mance" listed on your site.  It contains the designation    5" MK 5    and the letters   W. & J.G. and, the word NIVOC inside a diamond shape.  And  # 822068  I have the basic unit, with the "Station Mirror". The stiff leather carrying case is in perfect condition.  The unit itself is almost perfect with little wear.  I'd just like to know a bit more about it.  I have some pictures I could e-mail if you like.  And any information you might share would be appreciated.  [Mike, unfortunately I have almost no information on the dating and manufacturing location of the Mark V and its predecessors.  But, hopefully, there is someone out there that can help us.]

******************************************

Michael Barnwell   New York City, NY    11 May 2003    Thank you for creating this website. I recently came across a heliograph displayed in nautical supply store window and was intrigued with the instrument. I knew nothing about the history of the instrument, but was simply drawn to the beauty of its design. Having once been a surveyor for a brief time in the oil fields of Louisiana, I was even more drawn to it having learned about its signalling function.   I would very much like to purchase an authentic, antique heliograph, and was wondering if you could help me in my search. I was interested mainly in the two-mirror circular-shaped style (is this the Mark V Mance I saw on the site?). Any help you could provide would be appreciated. I live in New York City, so proximity would be a concern, but not a limitation.  Thank you Sincerely, Michael Barnwell     [I find eBay to be the only reliable, continuing source of heliographs, mostly the Mark V (as you described), a model patterned after Sir Henry Mance's original 1870s patented model as described in my website.  There usually is a bidding scramble in the last couple of minutes, so most early bidding only tends to raise the price.  Often they are offered by "northeasterners", but at no particular advantage in the U.S.   [Interestingly, Mike, I was also a surveyor; with USN Seabees in early 50s.  Surveying is a helpful background for using the heliograph...Jim].

******************************************

Jack Hammen    Prescott    KC6TRX    09 May 2003                   Jim   I did not know that you had "immortalized" me on the internet until today.  Jack KC6TRX  [Jack, consider yourself twice "immortalized".]

******************************************

Miles Swarthout     Playa del Rey, California    05 Apr 2003                           Dear James Riddle!  --  I changed my email address after a move last fall, so I lost track of your for awhile. But you should know that my new Western novel set against the backdrop of Gen. Nelson Miles's new heliograph network in the Apache War of 1886 is now out in the bookstores or available from Barnes & Noble on-line. The Sergeant's Lady is getting great reviews, which can be found on Amazon on-line, or on our literary website, www.glendonswarthout.com . This whole novel is about the heliographs, and I believe it is the first Western to use this new signal network in the Army as the backdrop for its story, in this case a romance between a divorced rancher's sister and a Sergeant of Scouts, who is placed in charge of one of these sites ringing the Sulphur Springs Valley not too far from Ft. Bowie while he recuperates from a leg wound. The plot should remind one a little of Louis L'Amour's first and best novel, Hondo, which starred John Wayne and Geraldine Page (an Oscar nominee for Best Actress in this fine film) back in 1950...   And please keep up your fine educational program about the heliographs and Arizona's fascinating military history.

******************************************

Karemera Alphonse         04 Apr 2003             A friend of mine came to me and asked me about an instrument called Heliograph (Cassella London MK.III.A) and told me" can you please tell me what this instrument does, its price "I then broused from internet and got this website but until now I haven't  yet found sufficient information  of that type of heliograph.  I would please ask you, if possible to give me the necessary informations on it (its use,price, manufacturer,etc)  Waiting for your response, I thank you.

******************************************

Petra Henderson      2 Apr 2003       Newsletter editor, acting Secretary and Historian of the Royal Signals Organisation UK, a closed membership non-profit veterans group set up for serving and ex-members of the Britsh Royal Corps of Signals. http://www.royal-signals.org.uk                      Hello James,  Thank you for your kind permission to use your photo, and the offer to link the on-line version of the data-sheet from your group once it has been created... Very kind.  Also thank you for your compliments on the compilation, nice to hear, then it is not just a datasheet or history document, but should be a bit of fun and interesting to read, so as not to be too dry... Odd Humour is my speciality! ;-) ...  I am sure that amoung your Heliography fans, you will have the occasional ex-forces member who may like to be pointed in the direction of the Royal Signals Org website, and look forward to periodic contacts... Thanks again, 73s and 88s  Petra  [Their site on �Heliography� is at http://www.royal-signals.org.uk/indexes/datasheets_index.htm   and on �CHAPTER IV THE HELIOGRAPH (PAGE 48 OF THE 1905 SIGNALLING HANDBOOK)� at http://www.royal-signals.org.uk/datasheets/heliograph01_p01.htm  .  BTW, I listed the Royal Signals website sometime back under �Related Links� and, I believe �Events Photos� �� Jim]

******************************************

MikeGreenfield    N9JIY    Jackson, WI     19 Mar 2003 ....I just finished building my first helio & it seems to work very well!  Used "self-aiming liferaft type" mirror I got for $6 + $10 in simple oak parts & brass hardware.  Made w handtools only, but looks pretty gud anyway.  Sits on $19 Walmart camera tripod.    Keys like a dream at wat feels like abt 10wpm.     I hauling it to ham club mtgs & fests to stir up interest cuz need op on other end of helio QSO!    I get son to shoot digital pics & snd
to you!   73!    Mike

******************************************

David Vleck      KA3SNY    Baltimore,  MD    11 Mar 2003               Hello, Jim. -- I'm a friend of Fred, N7PJN.  He suggested that I send you an e-mail  regarding a heliograph that I saw in a Randolph Scott movie some weeks ago. My father and I enjoy watching western movies on the Western Channel, via  satellite.  While awaiting for the movie we intended to watch, we tuned into  a Randolph Scott movie in progress.  After researching the name of the movie  via the Internet Movie Database, I finally found the title..........The  Walking Hills (1949)....about treasure hunters seeking a wagon load of gold  buried in Death Valley.  I won't bore you with the details, since I only caught the end of the movie anyway.  But the character played by John Ireland, used a portable heliograph  to signal a compatriot in the desert scene.  The heliograph was basically mounted on a short "board", perhaps a foot to a foot and a half long.  It had the mirror mounted on the user end.... with the signal shutters in the middle... and a sort of "front sight", for want of a useful description, on the other end, with a sort of aperture or ball on a short post, like one would use for an aiming device as on a rifle.  The heliograph was perhaps about 6" in height.  It was difficult to get good feature details from the brief movie scenes, but that gives you an idea of what it was like.  I also got the impression the unit was collapsible to a degree, since the character had it buried in one scene in some sort of smaller sack. I don't know if you can research this at all......and I don't know if you can  somehow  view the movie yourself.  But from the info Fred has sent me on your  activities with the heliograph demonstrations, I was able to identify the  movie prop as a  heliograph immediately.  [David, I found a really washed out copy of �Walking Hills� on eBay.  The Hg, shown about 45 minutes in, is an �American Service Model�, but situation (in hand, in sand) is totally off the wall.  I think that most folks interested in the Hg may be interested in picking up a copy, although I think it put me to sleep a half-dozen times before I finished it.  Many thanks, Jim]

 ******************************************

MikeGreenfield/N9JIY    27 Feb 2003           I've got my camera tripod & a "self-aiming" signaling mirror to homebrew a helio.     Can you refer me to any descriptions, pix, dwgs, etc of successful homebrew helios using these??    Also, anything re helios using plastic CDs as mirrors??      Tnx!    PS:   I get to PHX x2/yr, maybe give you a holler sumtime!

******************************************

Don Steven    Minneapolis   MN    25 Feb 2003                  Nice site, with a lot of good information. Do you know where I could buy an original hg? Or do you know anyone who has exact plans for building one?  I became interested in heliographs when I was stationed at Fort Huachuca in 1959, and I saw a good article in Arizona Highways on their use in the Indian Wars.  I think low-technology is way underrated.  Thanks. 

******************************************

Rachel Matthews               London, UK              11 Feb 2003                      Hi, I am desperately trying to find 20 pocket heliographs for an expedition in Namibia in April. I work for a television company & we are taking a group of children to work with endangered black rhinos in the desert. I cannot find a manufacturer anywhere, please could you help me??? I am London based.  Many Thanks, Rachel Matthews.  [Note:  Ms Matthews soon found the need pocket heliographs � Jim]

******************************************

Conrad From       Worcester   MA       09 Feb 2003                                                  Dear Mr. Riddle,  My interest in heliographs comes partially through the novels of Larry Niven (The Integral Trees and The Smoke Ring). Rather than bore you with synopses (you can find them on line if you want), I'll just say that heliographs were used in the latter novel and since reading them I've been fascinated with the idea of thinking of new (old) technologies that could be used again, and the heliograph is one of them. Your site is very interesting and informative. I've often speculated on how history might have been different if, for example, a rapid communications system had been available during the American Revolution. There are a couple reasons why it wasn't developed (1) mirrors were expensive and had to be imported from England in the early colonial days. (2) the Puritan influence against personal vanity mitigated against their availability, and (3) as far as I know, the techniques for chemically plating a thin layer of gold on, say, steel, had not been invented. Gold would be nearly as good a reflector as silver or mercury on glass, and it would not rust as polished steel could. Of course, it would be a target for thieves.... Anyhow, I appreciate your site, and while heliographs are not my sole or even primary interest, your work is greatly appreciated. Your site has a nice professional appearance. If you should happen to learn about any more primitive, ancient heliographs, the mica variety or others, I would like to hear of them.  Cordially yours,  Conrad From

******************************************

January 16, 2003   ESME GLEESON 
  Interesting (website), I have been given a heliograph 5 IN MK V 1943 AUGUST.  Until now I never knew what it was!!  It seems it is an interesting item, but I am missing its tripod.  Please can you advise me on where I can obtain a period tripod.           Reply: Well, Esme, congratulations on getting an Hg (quick as mercury), and then finding out about it on this website.  Expect to pay as much as a c-note for a Mk 3 tripod (for Mk5 Hg).  The most economical source for finding a tripod of which I am aware is eBay, but competition for Hg items is great.  I, too, am looking for a tripod, so good luck.  Jim Riddle

******************************************

January 15, 2003   Jay Miller   WA5WHN  Albuquerque, New Mexico
    Very interesting (map on your website) since the Ft. Stanton to Nogal Peak path is almost in our back yard in Lincoln County.
    Any chance of a demonstration at the ARRL AZ convention at Ft. Tuthill  (near Flagstaff) this year?
    A great resource for heliograph history.  My Wife (WB5LYJ) & I have seen broken mica pieces & quartz near the signal fires close to Chaco Canyon. What is more interesting is the roads that were constructed during that period of time to and from Chaco. I believe there is a NASA web page showing those roads from on high. They had to use those signal fires for communications.              
Reply: 
Hi Jay,    Yes, I will consider Tuthill for setting up an Hg demo.  Good Idea (weather permitting), and Tnx fer comments on mica being found at Chaco Canyon, New Mexico, that’s new and exciting to me, and I'm sure to others.   73s, Jim Riddle

******************************************

January 5, 2003  Nancy Newton   Washington DC
    Hi, this is an extremely interesting web site.  I am a teacher and I am studying different forms of communication with my students.   Could you suggest an easy and inexpensive way to make a heliograph with the children?  I thank you for your time.
                                    Reply: A very simple Hg can be made from one or two small mirrors) often free from a glass company) and a sight.  Just draw a 1/4" hole on back of the first (called sun or simplex) mirror, and scratch silver from circle with a knife tip.  For second mirror (station or duplex), fasten a 1/4" white circle to center of 2nd mirror.  You can use about anything for a sighting rod (needed only with sun mirror).   I made one for my little portable by fastening another 1//4" circle to its end, and placing it in the hole that would otherwise be holding the second (duplex).   We will leave it up to your class to figure out the mirror frame, etc.   A simple shutter, or handheld piece of cardboard will suffice for the "screen".  Also a common 1/4" tripod can be used with Hg, and another for the shutter (if constructed).  (See 3" RidKo on "homemade Hgs" on my website.)

******************************************

December 21, 2002    John Blocher    Cincinnati, Ohio
   This is an excellent website for describing heliography.  I found this site after reading several survival books where something called a 'heliograph' was mentioned and did a Yahoo search.
   Especially helpful on your site is the description of range (10 miles per inch of mirror diameter) and flash diameter (49 feet per mile).  People are out there claiming that a 2"x3" (brand omitted) Signal Mirror can be seen for 100 miles.
   I realize that your sight is primarily aimed at "fixed station-to-fixed station" communication, but there is an entire emergency signal mirror industry in existence.  It seems to me the ultimate communication is the emergency flash from someone stranded on land or at sea, and in need of rescue.
   Anyway, you might want to think about adding a small section related to hand-held emergency signalling.  At least include the common advice that a person should carry a signal mirror when hiking off the beaten trail or have one attached to their PFD (along with a storm whistle) if boating in an area away from shore.  There is a variety of information on the internet (especially from people selling them), much of it misleading.
   I have no connection with the emergency signal mirror industry.  Actually, I am concerned that people might think they need an "official" (and expensive) signal mirror when they could either use a regular mirror or make their own.
   This is a good site, and I've learned a great deal about the heliograph from reading it!  I'm more than a little tempted to look for one of those Portuguese heliographs that looks like it could be mounted on a rifle in place of a scope.

 

Reply:  John, I agree with you regarding the importance of the handheld mirror for emergency signaling, and have a collection of several.  However, as you say, the theme of the website deals primarily with "intelligent", two-way (usually) communications between stations.  Often, signaling a position in front of you and the sun behind you becomes impossible with a single mirror, which makes me wonder, why not try out a second mirror with, say, a 1/4" white dot at its center?  I'm sure such an arrangement would at least occasionally flash the target.  See Chuck Bowan's entry of October 18, 2002 below…Jim Riddle

 

******************************************

October 21, 2002  John W.Alcorn, VK2JWA    LISMORE, New South Wales, Australia

Hi Jim (Riddle), Tom, Leith, Rob, John

   I finished today a small accessory I have had in mind for some time for my Helio equipment. This is a "Training Mirror" to assist in practicing or demonstrating the Helio. It is a convex mirror used as a target to observe the signal flashes.

   This has several advantages over a plane mirror or other targets. It does not have to be accurately aligned for the observer to see the flashes. The bright flash is reduced in intensity and size so creating an illusion of distance. The flash is still distinctive but can be observed by a group up to about 40 degrees off the centreline.

   The mirror used is a 135mm (5") adhesive type for fitting on a flat mirror. It cost about $2.50 at any auto accessory supplier. This size is completely illuminated by the beam of the 5" Mk V Helio. Removing the self-adhesive pads, they are not reliable; I fitted a back plate with a 6.5mm spigot.

   This mounts on my Stand, Insts, No21, MkV and, with an adaptor, Stand, Inst. No14, Mk II. 1915. These Stands will also mount the Duplex Helio mirror if wished. Others would make fittings to suit the stands they are using. I also fitted a small sighting tube for easier alignment but this is not
essential but handy. The pictures (see "Homemade Hg's" for an example) show the various set ups.
  (See page  http://au.photos.yahoo.com/hamradio_au
NB. If anyone wants any of these pics, contact me for a download.
Yahoo only downloads a degraded (300x400) pic on the free pages.)
  
73, John.      Reply:  John, thanks so much!  I put your idea to excellent use at a recent demonstration for the recent Victorian Holiday Celebration at Heritage Square in the Civic Center in downtown Phoenix, Arizona.  I purchased a 5” (12,7 cm) wide (grand) angle mirror at a local auto parts store.  The mirror is equipped with and ball/socket joint and adjustable clamping device that perfectly matched the lower end of the staff of a wigwag signal flag (see "Homemade Hg's"@@@).  As luck would have it, I had but about 20 yards   for the demonstration between the flag with its mirror, and the heliograph, so that it worked brilliantly!  Many thanks again your many contributions.

73, Jim Riddle, Prescott AZ

******************************************

October 2, 2002 +/-       Roger Dewhurst         Rotorua,        New Zealand.            Hello, I found your page when looking for information on heliographs.  I want to be able to aim light from a mirror at an electronic detector on a kite.  I would be very grateful for any suggestions you can make.  The kite is a fishing kite and may be 400 metres away.  I can design an electronic circuit which will drop the hooks and bait if I can aim the beam adequately. Reply:  Unfortunately Roger’s e-mail address was lost, but hopefully someone will let him know about the following suggestions (a few others were lost):

Bill Plumpe writes:  If he just wants to send the kite a flash, I suggest that he look for one of the WWII liferaft signaling mirrors.  They have some type of reflecting layer in the center view hole that gives the user a light spot on the object that the beam is aimed at.  I have one, and it is really remarkable how they highlight the target.  I haven't completely figured it out.  Anyway, they are only about the size of a playing card so he can carry one in a pocket.  BTW, the graphics you are using with your emails cause blank spots in the copy.  Playing with the image, such as clicking "select all" and scrolling helps but it acts like there was an invisible image covering the writing. 

Bob Rosevear, WB7RRQ:  This guy just has way to much time on his hands!

John Goldfinch:  Received your E to Ben F. Ridge informing us all of your change of web address and incidentally of the HG fishing poser. Did your replies include the double-sided mirror with the bare centre spot for sighting or the Robertson emergency helio, courtesy of John Alcorn?   I have tried a double-sided metal mirror in which I drilled a hole which worked well, also a ladies handbag mirror using a corner for sighting rather than a centre hole/bare patch. I have taken the liberty of attaching a diagram to show the principle just in case this method has previously escaped the net of your interest.  [John included an illustration including the use of the hand-mirror, an eye, and Roger’s kite]

Jack Hammen, KC6TRX, I suggest the use of a photocell activated release mechanism attached to the kite.  Adjust so ambient light does not activate, but flash from mirror does.  Radio control sounds more practical, but it's not solar.

******************************************

October 18, 2002     Chuck Bowan     North Dakota

I ran across this site while looking for heliograph info.  I think I hit the jackpot.   I hope (the following) helps...Chuck Bowen                                                               Signal Corps Association Reenactors Division (SCARD)     Posted By: Walt Mathers on: 10/17/2002 22:49:17 MDT      Subject: Civil War Era Heliograph Question, Reply To    Message Detail:  In reply to your post concerning heliographs.    While at Rockville, Maryland during 1863 US Signal Corps Captain (later Bvt. Major) Earnest A. Denicke made some successful efforts to communicate with the station at Poolesville (some eight or ten miles distance)by means of small hand-mirrors reflecting the rays of the sun
(heliograph) Orders came for the army to move and the experiments were suspended. They were, however, re-new'd and proved successful, in November, 1864, while Captain Denicke was stationed at New Orleans, Louisiana.   I've hear tell that the Confederates were also experimenting with mirrors down in the Valley especially around Massanutten [sp?] Mtn. ...  Tnx for coming to SCARD's signal site. We hope you return again and again and tell others what we have to share and what we have come to know as the meeting place for communicating minds.   Much Success~  Walt Mathers
Website for: Signal Corps Association (1860-1865)

Reply:  Many thanks, Chuck.   So, it does appear that both sides may have used hand mirrors for signaling.   But, there still is no obvious evidence of using an instrument with some way of interrupting the sun beam into flashes for a code, as with a heliograph.  Jim

******************************************

Oct 12, 2002         Ed Butler           KF6DXX                 Southern California                 We are trying to drum up interest in a late November mirror signal between Black Mountain (near Glamis Ca.) and Garnet Peak in the Laguna Mountains east of San Diego. This will be a 95 mile path if the weather cooperates but it may be a simple flashing experiment w/o Morse code being sent.

******************************************

Sept. 08, 2002   Charles Bowen     North Dakota   Hi Tom [Kosel]:  My name is Chuck Bowen. I ran across your heliograph on the net. I live in North Dakota, which has a very rich frontier military history. I have seen pictures in the past of military heliographers using mirrors in ND. Re-enacting is a very big thing in ND with several Cavalry units active. Custer’s 7th was stationed at Ft. Lincoln D.T. not far south of Bismarck ND.I don't believe we have any Signal Corps re-enactors, which is a shame. I would like to remedy this but, as I am at the beginning of my search, know very little about heliography.    From all I've seen of heliographs, yours looks most like what I remember seeing. I would like to correspond with someone who knows the business and would appreciate any help.                       Reply:   Thank you, Chuck, Tom Kosel forwarded your letter to me for answering, as he considers me the more “knowledgeable” on such matters (which is another way of saying that he would rather someone else handle his e-mail).  It is true that Tom’s heliograph is the most similar “production” model, based on the “American” heliograph pattern available.   He is considering making a smaller “Kosel Model”, say 4�” on a fixed stand of about 36” height, but needs lots of encouragement from folks like you and me to do it.  Without gearing, and being made of wood, this could be a low-cost instrument available finished or in kit form, and would be perfectly suitable for reenactments or demonstrations.  Tom has already made at least six larger working 8” “Kosel Service Models” [see "Homemade Hgs" on this website], and has the shop and equipment to make the smaller ones, too.   Tom’s problem is that he just has two many irons (or should I say “saws”) in the fire, but maybe we can get his priorities redirected towards the heliograph once again.                                                           Hope that this has been helpful.  If you haven’t already done so, you might want to take a look at the current (Summer) issue of “Military Classics Illustrated” that includes an excellent article on heliography.   Good luck with your interests, and maybe you can become the first Signal Corps re-enactor in the Dakotas.  It is known that the Hg (quick as mercury) saw same use in the plains, but mostly for trying it out to test its feasibility as a communications device.  Jim Riddle

******************************************

Aug 13 2002            Mike Castrucow              VE7MK/VA7MPC                                                               Hi James  I heard about you from Lynn Burlingame, N7CFO.   Met him at the RAC Convention in Vernon BC a few weeks ago. I was showing a couple of guys a signaling mirror I had just made and he came over to chat. His comment was that he didn't think he would find someone as crazy as him at the convention. He told me about your web site. I have been playing with simple mirrors for many years but have also been interested in heliographs for quite some time.
    Spent my whole life as a surveyor and mirrors have come in handy for me
numerous times over the years. Lynn mentioned that you have a mailing
list that you use on occasion and that I may be able to get on it. I would
appreciate it as I would like to learn as much as I can about heliographs.
    I do have a couple of list serves of my own, one for local PC user club
members and another one for hobby gold miners. It is fun all around.
Thanks  Mike Castrucow    VE7MK/VA7MPC    Ann Castrucow      VE7MKD

******************************************

July 27, 2002         William Plumpe,    W0ETR         St. Louis, Mo.                                      Dear Mr. Riddle,    I found your web site in a search for information about heliographs.  I have a Mk 5 helio in virtually new condition, but with no tripod or instructions.  I have fairly well worked out the procedure and would like to correspond with others who use them and try communicating with it.  Being in St. Louis, I am a bit out of range for you, but I have some friends in the Morse Telegraph Club who would help.  I especially would like to find the proper tripod.  I have a heavy camera tripod that I can adapt it to, but of course the original would be better.                                                               [PLUMPE CONT  8/8/02]    We considered giving a helio demonstration at the National Museum of Transport's open house last weekend, but there just wasn't time to make an adapter and set it up.  I can make one since I have a machine shop, but I would rather find an original tripod.  For background, I have a small business manufacturing and remanufacturing electrical components for locomotives. We do other work as well, but mostly we are like a remora hanging on a shark, or the birds that clean alligator's teeth, living off crumbs from General Electric.  It isn't as good a living as I could make in the corporate world, but I do have a degree of independence I couldn't have there.  As to hobbies, I have had a ham license, W0ETR, since 1951 and am VP of the Antique Radio Collectors & Historians (ARCH, naturally, this is St. Louis), but I don't really collect radios, more tubes and scientific instruments, as well as anything that relates to communication.  I have three display cases of such items in my living room, including a genuine South Congo talking drum.  Now there would be a real demonstration, sending a message by old fashioned telegraph to a helio site and doing the third relay leg in drum talk. It is possible.  Anything that can be said in Bantu can be said in drum.  BTW, a couple of years ago there was an article, I think from a magazine but possibly a book, that claimed to be the most complete account of the helio activities during the indian wars on Ebay.  I bid on it, but it went out of my range.  Do you remember it, and did you get it?  Thank You,   Bill Plumpe

******************************************

May 21, 2002    Richard Hammer                                                                                           Hi James,  Many many years ago heliographs were used to signal between Rottnest Island, [Australia] and the mainland.  There are pictures showing this in the Rottnest museum. I would like to suggest to the Rottnest Historical Society that recreating a heliograph and demonstrating it, even if only between two high points on the island, would be a very exciting project with many benefits.
However, I would prefer to approach the society with more than just an idea. Could you suggest where I might obtain more information about heliographs which may have been used, or plans, or anything really.  Thank you, Dr. Richard Hammer, Senior Analyst, Rutherford, Ernest (1871-1937)

******************************************

Hi Folks,

        Thought you might enjoy some recently exchanged letters between Mike Stanway of the UK, myself and John Alcorn regarding an "artsy" heliograph Mike has planned:

 

Dear Mr. Riddle,

Some time ago I became interested in the idea of constructing a series of windpowered, revolving (either vertically or horizontally) heliographs. The purpose of this experiment was to set up a "visual link" across a large area of country, i.e.. If you can see hill "a" from hill "b" but not from hill "c" a visual link exists if you have a heliograph on each hill. Its a conceptual art idea in a way but not completely.  I did construct some heliographs on poles but the range from which they could be seen was very limited 2 or 3 miles though even they revolved. They were about 10 inches square, stainless steel and fairly flat.  I did bend some in a flattened "s" section that improved the rpm but not the visibility.   Where did I go wrong and what range could I hope to achieve?

Regards, Mike  Stanway (7-7-02)

 

Mike,

What a novel idea!  No reason it shouldn't work, but distance of flash will depend on the mirror's brilliance, "flatness", and size; and, most important of all, of course, meteorological condition.

As you may have learned from my website, the "cone of visibility" of the reflected sun (for a flat mirror) increases at approximately 49' per mile, and the "range of visibility" is typically 10 miles per inch in diameter for a good mirror under clear conditions.

The "hang time" of the reflected light will vary with the angle of the sun, but ordinarily you might expect to see the reflected flashes from one to two minutes without further adjustment of the mirror.  A slightly convexed mirror will have much longer "hang time", but the length of flash will, of course, be substantially reduced.

Naturally, a number of mirrors set at different angles from the vertical, as you know, will allow the flashes to be seen briefly at different times of day from any vantage point visible from the mirror.  You may find the "heliotrope" website listed on my webpage, "Related Websites" of interest.

Do you have "drivers" separate from the mirrors?  Of course, such a device could be solar powered, there being no need for rotation when there is no sun, anyway…Jim in Prescott AZ, USA (7/7/02)

 

JIM,

        Thanks for your prompt reply and all the info I don’t have any pics of the mk 1 but my enthusiasm has been rekindled I wonder whether a multiple setup might work ie a frame with a number of revolving mirrors within it.  Actually bike wheel hubs are a great readymade base for spinners but the science of these things escapes me.  For instance is it better to have a flat surface revolving or flip-flopping (I'm sure that's not the right expression).

       Anyway as to powering the movement of the mirrors they are directly wind powered which works fine.  Here in the UK we have a network of triangulation pillars on hilltops all visually linked.  Each of them has a bronze theodolite mounting on top that is tapped to about a 3 inch diameter thread.  As they are all no longer in use but mostly in good condition they will suit my purposes admirably (do you have them in the USA?).

       Instead of talking about this I should do something about it.  I will do some drawings at some point and send you some photos when I get going. I don’t know about you but I have a list of "things to do" which is measured in light years!!!

       I think your site is excellent (isn’t the internet wonderful?), use any of my stuff you want for what it's worth and keep the good work up.  Regards…Mike (7-9-02)

Hi Mike,

       Interesting about the theodolite mountings in the UK.  Don’t know of any here (in the USA), but maybe someone else has some information on this.  I am aware of triangulation points, usually of brass, set in rock or concrete on many of the mountaintops, very common “out west”.  Instruments (theodolites, heliographs, heliotropes, etc.) were set up over the points for mapping (and communicating), each tied into the other.  Like the thought of your utilizing the existing 3-inch bases if possible, but wonder about their durability under heavy winds.

        Don’t have a clue as to “revolving or flip-flopping”, but might want to give consideration to both sides of glass being mirrored, and keeping your “heliograph” as simple as possible.  Stay in touch…Jim (7-12-02)

PS    Mike, Having received your permission, am sending these letters on to my readers, and may post the letters to my website.  Hopefully, some of the folks out there have some thoughts on your "artsy" heliograph project, and can get in touch with you at your address, mike.stanway@btinternet.com …Jim

 

John W.Alcorn, VK2JWA   7/14/02 (with more on "Artsy" heliograph)

Hi,  To create a flashing beacon that would be mostly visible from most points
and angles has to take into account a basic variable. Won't work on cloudy days or at night. Hihi [ham talk for laughing]. Neither will a HG. That's the funny bit. Has to allow for the varying incident angles as the sun transits its orbit.
The only contrivance that can approach this is the 'party ball' design seen
in night clubs and other illuminated decorations. Of course only the top hemisphere would be required, as the bottom half would not be illuminated or reflect incident rays above the horizontal.
To make a reasonable flash, larger segments would need to be used than is
used in these balls, probably up to 2" in size. This would mean less segments to the hemisphere. The larger the hemisphere, the more segments. This would simply be a mechanical limitation of the constructor. They would need to be fitted in an incremental pattern as a spiral up from the equator to cover as many incident angles as possible.  Such a hemisphere would be easy to mount to rotate on a vertical shaft driven by cups at its equator similar to anemometer. It would not be practical to leave these on hilltops as vandals would soon wreck them. In OZ (Australia)the survey points are called Trigonometrical Points ( Trig Points) and are usually a concrete pillar, stone pile or steel post topped with
blackened circular disks aligned NS - EW. These are mutually visible from the next points for survey purposes. It is illegal to build any structure that obscures these lines of sight. They do suffer damage from vandals, see pic at the VK2RBB site. I hope these thoughts are useful.  73, John W.Alcorn, VK2JWA

 

******************************************

July 5, 2002     Joe Marques             Hi Jim,  This is Joe in Flagstaff and I met you at Ft. Verde Days.  I was doing some research in old Flagstaff newspapers and found something that might interest you.  In the Arizona Weekly Champion, Saturday August 7, 1886, page 2 column 1, it says: "A message was recently sent by the government heliograph (signalling by sunlight flashes) from Fort Cummings, N.M. to Tubac, Ariz., a distance of 400 miles, and an answer received in four hours."                                  Happy signalling!  Joe
    And Hi to you Joe!  What a great find!  Wasn't aware of it.  This was during the Geronimo Campaign of 1886, and the heliograph system of 1886 did indeed extend between the two stations.  From Tubac, the most westerly terminus, the intermediate stations were Baldy Peak (or possibly Josephine Peak just a little south of Baldy), Fort Huachuca, Antelope Spring, Emma Monk, White's Ranch, Bowie Peak (or Helen's Dome), Steins Peak, and Camp Henely (east of Fort Cummings).  The messages were relayed seven times, each way.  These most likely were test messages, and relatively short, but would love to know what they really said, how many words were lost, etc..  The 1886 "airline" distance between Tubac and Fort Cummings is 241 miles, with round trip of course being 482 miles.  See "Map of Hg Sites" herein.  Many thanks, Jim Riddle

******************************************

Stan Dolan                                                                                         Thursday, 5/16/02 Hello Jim,  Looks like a nice web site. I am putting together a British Mk V and should have it done shortly. I need to strip the paint to the brass to make it Boer War period. I was interested to see the Boer War example on your site having the aiming device. First one I have seen from that period with one.
Cheers, Stan Dolan

******************************************

Ed Zeranski                                                                                        Thursday, 5/9/02 James,   Last weekend, May 3-5, the West Coast Military Radio Collector's Group had our annual get together at Fort MacArthur in San Pedro, CA.   Bart Rowlett WB6HQK had a display and demonstration of a Mance Heliograph and various military signal lights. For me it was one of the highlights of the meet, I'm hooked!!!  Your site was found during a helio-search on the web. I don't know where I'll find an instrument so will have to dig up plans or design my own.
Ed Zeranski, San Diego, CA

******************************************

Stan Rohrer,                      W9FQN@Juno.com                               Thursday, 4/4/02    Jim,  We have a group here in San Diego County that likes to climb mountains and then we many times like do mirror flashing. Our record probably is over 90 miles now two way; we have even sent Morse Code over much shorter distances.
    Do you know of anyone or any group that is into this type of signaling?
    If so, it would be nice to pick up some e-mail addresses or possibly phone numbers to make contact.
    John Wilson, KM6BF (Pres., Yavapai Amateur Radio Club, Prescott, AZ) was kind enough to suggest you as possibly being able to point us in the right direction.  (2nd letter from Stan dated 4/10/02 adds) ... we have a group that likes to hike ... and to FLASH ... they make a good combination ..and it is good for amateur radio since people are attracted to what we are doing and then they hear us coordinating the operation on 2m ... and they try to help spot where the flashes are coming from.  we always hand them mirrors and teach anyone who is interested in how to use them.  73, Stan   Palomar Amateur Radio Club  San Diego County Hikers

******************************************

Rick Peterson,                 WA6NUT, wa6nut@arrl.net                 Thursday, 3/28/02
Dear KD7AOI,
    After checking [another] URL for the past several months (I had read about that web site on the W7YRC site), I discovered that it had been moved to your present URL.  Many thanks to you for providing a site full of good info on heliograph communications!
    I've been interested in heliography for a while, having bought W9CNY's book
back in 1992.  I've wondered if the ARRL would consider a new category,
incoherent light, for DX records for the "World Above 50 MHZ".  It's
interesting to note that the current DX record for coherent light, 149
miles (set by WA7LYI and KY7B in 1991) falls short of the 183 mile
heliograph DX worked by the Signal Corps in 1894!   This work is recorded
in W9CNY's book, p. A12.  Thanks again for providing the Heliography web site!   73's, Rick  P.S.:  How about a Heliography Net on HF? (20M or ?)

******************************************

Fred W. Boughton

Monday, 11/26/01, 4:37 PM

 
  Jim, Sorry to see your Homepage go by the wayside. That's "Progress" I guess. "Bait and Switch!" Hope to see a new web site in future--and participate in local "heliograph" activities and discussions. 73 Fred KB2CT 26 Nov 01, Prescott, AZ  

******************************************

Zyg Nilski

Saturday, 11/24/01, 2:50 PM

Sorry to hear of problems Jim. Here's hoping that you can be up and running with another ISP as quick as possible - preferably at the speed of light!
From: Shropshire, UK
Web Site: www.morsemag.com
E-mail: zyg@morsemag.com
call sign:  G3OKD

******************************************

Dolan McDonald

Friday, 11/9/01, 3:48 PM

Ran into Jim Riddle on a trail in Prescott. I learned the power of mirrors observing ground firefighters from my vantage point in a slurry bomber high above. I live at the bottom of Glassford Hill, home of the Ft. Whipple heliograph site. Have fun you flashers!
From: Prescott, Arizona
E-mail: dolanmcd@earthlink.net

******************************************

Pastor Doug Shepherd

Thursday, 11/8/01, 7:03 PM

  Just found your interesting web site! I found an old military heliograph here in the Azores dating from around WW II made at a munitions factory (Fabrica de Bra�o de Prata) in Lisbon. Your site has interested me in finding out more!
  From: Azores Portugal
  E-mail: shepherd@ip.pt

******************************************

STEPHEN R. ALEXANDRICH     KG4ART
I WOULD LIKE TO BUILD OR PURCHASE A HELIOGRAPH. BEEN READING ABOUT BRITISH USE OF THE INSTRUMENT IN THEIR COLONIAL MILITARY ADVENTURES.
Norman Shackley

Monday, 10/8/01, 10:25 AM

Great site -- full of interest.
From: London, England
Web Site: Vanuatu South Pacific
E-mail: nshackley@lineone.com
call sign:  G0OSX & YJ8JS

******************************************

Tom Barker Saturday, 8/18/01, 11:54 PM
Hi Jim, I was attached for a while to Glub Pasha's Arab Legion before WW2. We often used the heliograph to send messages from hill top to hill top in Palestine. Since radios in those day were so big and cumbersome and had to be transported by truck, there were times the trucks could not go where we wanted to go due to hilly terrain. Since a heliograph could be carried by one man they became invaluable as a means of communicating. The only drawback was they were useless on a rainy day when the sun was hidden by cloud. The ones we used had round mirrors. I often have wondered why some bright spark has not taken it any further. Since the mirror is the restricting agent of the sun's light why not fit a magnifying reflector behind and an enlarging lens at the front and get double the distance???? :0) think about it. :0)regards T
From: Western Australia
E-mail: tbarker@bigpond.net.au

******************************************

Helmut Saturday, 8/4/01, 4:40 AM
Read "HG" in Morsum Magnificat 76. Great to see Morse live on this way... 73 Helmut
From: Vienna, Austria
E-mail: kleinh@gmx.at
call sign:  OE1TKW

******************************************

Judi Robins Tuesday, 7/24/01, 7:52 PM
Interesting topic on your Website! Heard of it through local radio club. Hope to return soon.
From: Sun Valley, Nevada
Web Site:
E-mail: KD7GZR@arrl.net
call sign:  KD7GZR

******************************************

Ken Brown Monday, 7/23/01, 1:39 PM
My grandfather once told me that he and a friend once held a distance record for heliographing between Santa Catalina Island and somewhere such as Signal Hill or Telegraph Hill in or around Los Angeles. If anybody has any documentation of this I would love to see it. It would have occurred in the '20s, '30s or '40s (sorry I can't be more specific) His name was Claude P. Brown. Thanks, Ken Brown
From: Hilo, Hawaii
E-mail: kbrown@jach.hawaii.edu
call sign:  N6KB

******************************************

Pam Smith Tuesday, 6/12/01, 12:07 PM
Didn't realize there was a group of folk interested in heliograph stations. Glad to know you're out there. p
From: Las Cruces, NM
E-mail: pamsmith@zianet.com

******************************************

Harding Polk II Friday, 5/25/01, 11:58 AM
My father, a retired Army officer, first told me about heliographs. Later I was doing some historical research area of SW NM and learned more of them. What an amazing bit of history. Its surprising they weren't more actively used.
From: San Fidel, NM
E-mail: hpolk@swca.com

******************************************

Robert Coody Wednesday, 5/23/01, 8:26 AM
Huzzah!! I always wanted to do this, never had the time. Congratulations! Bob
From: Flagstaff
E-mail: robert.coody@nau.edu

******************************************

John Alcorn VK2JWA Tuesday, 4/24/01, 10:48 PM
Hi all, Thanks to Loralee beating me at Ebay I have made contact with you. Tks fr a vri gd sit. More to follow bt email. 73, John JWA.
From: Lismore, NSW, Australia
Web Site: Phonetic Alphabets, Historic, English and Others
E-mail: jalcorn@nor.com.au
call sign:  VK2JWA

******************************************

Fred W. Boughton Tuesday, 4/24/01, 8:58 AM
Jim, great web site. I'm glad to be a part of it. Perhaps this will generate much interest in the project. Looking forward to the next "exercise" event. Regards, Fred.
From: Prescott, AZ
E-mail: kb2ct@northlink.com
call sign:  KB2CT

******************************************

Al Witte Tuesday, 4/24/01, 6:33 AM
Jim, just found you site and think it is just great. You have done a wonderful job putting it together. I for one really appreciate the information and the effort to do it. When I have the time I sure will be a part of your effort from this side of the mountain. Thanks again for a fine web site. Al Witte
From: Sedona, Az
E-mail: alwitte@sedona.net
call sign:  KD6LZE